The Best Halal Italian Restaurants in NYC & Long Island

4.8

Pizza Loves Sauce

4.8

Yummy Cheese Pasta

If you're in Midtown Manhattan and need serious carbs fast, Yummy Cheese Pasta on 9th Ave is your go-to Italian spot. This casual, fast-casual restaurant knows exactly what it's doing—they've nailed craveable pasta that hits different when you're between meetings or post-theater. Their Fettuccine Alfredo is creamy and unapologetic, the Angry Garlic Shrimp packs a serious kick, and the Cheese Tortellini keeps it simple and perfect. Solid vegetarian options like Creamy Mushroom and Arrabiata round out the menu, with Fresh Lemonade to cut the richness. Boasting a 4.8 rating, this is peak casual dining for takeout or quick meals. Whether you're an office worker or Times Square tourist, you'll find reliable, no-fuss Italian-American pasta that doesn't require a big time commitment.

4.8

Gelatoville Gelataria & Coffee

4.7

109 Pizzeria

If you're hunting for legit halal pizza in Harlem, 109 Pizzeria on 3rd Avenue is exactly where you should land. This no-frills spot does one thing incredibly well: gets you fed fast without any pretense. The halal chicken nuggets are genuinely some of the best around—crispy, seasoned perfectly, made to order. Their pies? Solid. Hit the Halal Pepperoni or the BBQ Chicken if you're feeling adventurous. Everything on the menu is 100% halal, from the toppings to the fried chicken, which matters if that's important to you. The real draw here is the simplicity of it all—quick takeout, kind staff, prices that won't wreck your wallet, and food that actually delivers. Open 11am-7:35pm, 4.7 stars, and worth becoming a regular for.

4.7

Pink Pistachio Cafe

4.6

Lava Rock Kitchen

If you're looking for a halal spot that doesn't play it safe, Lava Rock Kitchen is doing something genuinely weird in the best way—think Beef Kofta Kabab sitting next to Lasagna Supreme and Shrimp Tempura on the same menu. This casual Bronx fusion house is where Italian comfort food, Asian techniques, and Middle Eastern flavors crash into each other, and honestly, it works. Order the Chicken Lollipop for that crispy-outside, tender-inside situation, chase it with their Sesame Chicken, then finish with NY Cheesecake. It's affordable, family-friendly, and packed with vegetarian options, making it the kind of neighborhood spot where everyone at your table can eat what they actually want. Perfect for takeout when you want something that feels special but doesn't require a reservation or a second mortgage.

4.5

El Forno Pizza & Grill

If you're in Ozone Park at midnight craving pizza that actually tastes like someone cared, El Forno Pizza & Grill is your answer. This spot serves up wood-fired style pies with an interesting twist—they're doing halal Italian, so you get that familiar crispy crust and quality mozzarella alongside dishes like the Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza, which somehow manages to not be gimmicky. The White Pie hits different (ricotta, garlic, no sauce), and if you're playing it safe, the Margherita won't disappoint. With family deals on pizza-and-wings combos and hours that stretch past 2 AM, it's perfect for late-night cravings or when you need to feed everyone on a budget. The takeout game is strong, reviews are consistently glowing, and the portions are generous. This is the kind of place you text your friends about at 11 PM.

4.5

Tesoro

If you're looking for proper Italian fine dining on Long Island, Tesoro in Westbury delivers the kind of elevated meal that justifies the drive. The dining room walks that fine line between dressed-up special occasion energy and genuinely welcoming—you can bring your family or pack it with a date and feel equally at home. The kitchen takes care with classics: tender calamari, perfectly charred eggplant, broccoli rabe with just the right amount of garlic bite. Their lamb chops arrive with impressive crust, and the rigatoni vodka tastes like someone actually knows what they're doing. The ricotta cheesecake is the real MVP—rich but not heavy, the kind of dessert that justifies finishing every last crumb. This is the restaurant you take people to when you want them to know you've got taste.

4.5

More Than Pizza Ithaca

More Than Pizza Ithaca isn't trying to reinvent the wheel—it's just giving you exactly what you need when you need it, at prices that actually make sense. This is the kind of place you hit up late night when you want something more interesting than your sixth slice of basic cheese pizza. The shawarma's got layers of spiced chicken that actually taste like someone cared, while the gyro hits different when you're hungry and broke (hello, college town). They're not precious about it—grab a Greek pizza or a buffalo chicken situation, pile on the toppings, and go. The falafel's solid, the garlic knots are the kind of side you don't need but absolutely get. At a 4.5-star rating with delivery and takeout always moving, this spot knows its lane and owns it. Perfect for when you want fast food that tastes like it has a pulse.

4.5

Majlis of NY

If you're tired of hookah lounges that feel like college bars, Majlis of NY is your answer. Tucked in Bellerose, this upscale spot serves 100% halal Mediterranean and Middle Eastern food in a sleek, modern space with actual ambiance. Order the jerk chicken—it's got a legitimate kick—but save room for the lamb gyro and kati rolls, all made like someone actually cared. The hookah and premium tea here are serious business, the staff treats you like a human, and the dress code keeps things refined without feeling pretentious. Perfect for date nights, celebrations, or just vibing with friends without the typical late-night chaos. This is the halal hookah lounge that's actually worth your time.

4.3

Milano Pizza & Pasta

Milano Pizza & Pasta is a no-frills Upper West Side spot that somehow pulls off a genuinely seamless fusion of Italian and Middle Eastern halal cuisine. You'll find thin-crust pizzas—both meat and veggie options—next to crispy falafel platters, hummus, and baba ghanoush that won't disappoint. The Grilled Chicken Alfredo Pasta hits that comfort-food sweet spot, and if you're looking for something lighter, the Greek and tabouli salads keep things fresh. It's the kind of casual, budget-friendly neighborhood joint where you can pop in for a quick lunch or order delivery for dinner. With a solid 4.3 rating and a family-friendly vibe, Milano delivers honest Mediterranean and Italian fare that doesn't take itself too seriously—and doesn't empty your wallet either.

4.2

La Bella Pizza Express

Bensonhurst's go-to spot for halal-certified pizza that won't wreck your wallet.[1] You're looking at massive slices, massive portions, and the kind of unfussy energy that keeps regulars coming back. A large pie runs thirteen bucks and lands with eight generous slices—perfect for sharing or, let's be real, eating alone while standing over the counter.[1] The menu spreads wide: baked lasagna that's heavy and satisfying, fried calamari that actually tastes good, crispy calzones, and specialty pies loaded with pepperoni and sausage. The vibe is pure neighborhood—tight space, quick service, zero pretension. Grab a Neapolitan round, throw some spinach rolls on the side, and you're set.[2][3] It's the kind of place where you walk in hungry and leave happy.

4.1

My Pizza and Restaurant

You'll find this Staten Island counter where halal pizza and Italian classics get equal respect. The crispy Garlic Knots are your warm-up act before you dive into a perfectly charred slice—the kind that crunches when you bite into it, then soaks your chin in grease and sauce. But stick around for the real stars: the Chicken Gyro and Lamb Gyro hit like you're not spending much, the Chicken Parmigiana comes golden and sauce-drenched, and the beef patties disappear fast. If you're feeding a hungry family on a budget, this is your spot. Fast casual, family-friendly, built for takeout. The 4.1 rating isn't there by accident. They know how to do the fundamentals right.

4.0

Queens College Diner

Queens College Diner is the kind of no-frills spot where you grab stellar chicken biryani at lunch and come back for fluffy pancakes the next morning without anyone raising an eyebrow. This Kew Gardens Hills institution leans into the anything-goes energy of its diverse neighborhood—butter chicken sits next to tacos, samosas hang out near pizza slices, and gyros arrive faster than you can sit down. It's fast casual in the best way: nothing fancy, but they've figured out how to execute across multiple cuisines without sacrificing quality. The breakfast is genuinely worth waking up for, and the prices won't make you wince. Bring family, bring coworkers, bring whoever's hungry and not too picky about ambiance. This is Queens eating at its most unpretentious and honest.

3.9

The Grounds Of Brooklyn

The Grounds of Brooklyn in Flatbush is handling the halal angle better than most: everything on the menu is certified, and the owner isn't shy about it. You're getting Italian and Mediterranean done right—proper spaghetti carbonara with actual richness, arancini that aren't afterthoughts, ravioli that works. But the real move is the grilled dorado or lamb shank pie if you want something with actual weight. It's casual and family-friendly, which means you can show up solo or bring the whole group without anyone sweating it. The prices won't hurt your wallet either. Grab the half-chicken with rosemary fries as your anchor, maybe a margherita pizza on the side. Delivery and takeout available if you're not trying to leave home.